卒業論文詳細

学科社会学科 ゼミ教員名MATTIAS VAN OMMEN 年度2024年度
タイトルThe Realities of Bukatsu: Power Dynamics and Resistance in Japanese School Clubs
内容 From the late 20th century to the present , bukatsu (extracurricular clubs) have flourished in Japanese schools. Generally , students who belong to bukatsu spend their time after school learning specialized knowledge in physical and cultural activities. Recently , the term "black bukatsu" has been coined and used in the media , evolving from "black company" where workers are overworked in Japan. It is because bukatsu sometimes causes problems that put a physical and emotional burden on students. In this study , I conducted interviews to find out what characteristics of bukatsu make students lose their resistance and accept harsh instructions. Six interviewees were asked comprehensively about their bukatsu experiences. As a result , common features of their experiences were clarified. First , they had acquired habitus or the unconscious cognition to generate one’s value and custom. They believe that it was right to endure severe ordeals. Second , they lost critical power due to attachment to or fear of their teachers. Third , seniority and meritocracy created hierarchies within students’ communities. The experience of bukatsu can influence the future because of their development of habitus. This study contributes to the discussion on how to improve bukatsu so it could be conducive to more positive effects for students and teachers.
講評 This thesis makes a contribution to the literature on extracurricular school clubs (bukatsu) , particularly in its consideration of how members either comply with or resist the social norms in their club. I appreciate the author’s willingness to receive and implement feedback , which I believe helped improve the focus of the thesis. I also liked how the author included vivid examples and personal experiences from an early stage of the conceptualization process , helping provide depth , nuance , and specificity to the thesis. In the end , I believe that the author convincingly gathered evidence to show how exactly members of school clubs lose their ability to resist school clubs and their demanding rituals and culture. I hope that this experience will give the author (and readers) confidence in the future , not only to conduct similar qualitative research , but also to maintain one’s agency to act rationally and resist unfair power structures where necessary.
キーワード1 Black Bukatsu
キーワード2 Resistance
キーワード3 Habitus
キーワード4
キーワード5